Reply To: Criteria needed for ratings

[andy-bandy]

hey man!
How are you doing? I really enjoy your attempt to make a discussion! Maybe – a theory of mine – the internet fora just haven’t been introduced to Wagner enthusiasts? (I’m sure many would have strong opinions) I think that the pappanos tristan is underrated, but i like other recordings much better (such as Furtwanglers, as you mentioned). Wether or not there should be criterias regarding the “cuts” of version I disagree with you. I think it shouldn’t be a question wether or not it is “correct”, but the message and “wholeness” of the piece. Shouldnt conductors be allowed to interpret pieces (as long as it isn’t disrespectful. Really man? Do you seriously consider Furtwaenglers ring “a questionable verdict” solely based on the “textual integrity”?!?!

sincerily

Andy

🙂